Organic Production Likely Improves Deadly Fungus Control in Carrots
October 7, 2020 
Purdue University scientist Lori Hoagland harvests carrots as part of her Alternaria dauci in organic soils research.
Photo courtesy of Purdue University
The fungus Alternaria dauci is one of the most damaging pathogens in carrots, killing leaves above the ground and sometimes rotting the vegetables growing in the soil. Crop protectants can be used to control the fungi, but they’re not widely available in developing countries and can’t be used in organic systems.
Purdue University scientists have another solution. Rather than spray above ground, they’ve found that cultivating microbes under the ground can help keep carrots safe from Alternaria dauci.
Extending Previous Research to Root Vegetables
The presence of some types of endophytes (bacteria that live symbiotically within a plant’s roots) can decrease the chances of carrots being damaged by A. dauci. Lori Hoagland, an Associate Professor in Horticulture and Landscape Architecture, and Sahar Abdelrazek, a former graduate student, wanted to know whether soil health and carrot genetics could affect the presence and number of endophyte communities that can suppress this pathogen in carrots.
“There has been a lot of research on how microbiomes affect human health and the more widely planted commodity crops. But this is one of the first studies to look at an important root vegetable crop like carrots,” says Hoagland, whose findings were published in the journal PLOS ONE. “We found that breeding and soil health can play significant roles in the number of endophytes present and their ability to protect carrots from this devastating disease.”
Organic Soil Likely Fends Off Disease
In field and greenhouse trials comparing soils and carrot genotypes, Hoagland and Abdelrazek found that crop management practices were connected with soil health and the number and diversity of endophytes that protected carrots from fungal disease.
The organic system had 16% more total soil organic matter and 43% more microbial biomass. Carrots grown in the organic system also had 50% more bacterial endophytes than those grown in the conventional system. Moreover, the organic carrots contained eight types of beneficial bacteria that could suppress the pathogen compared to only one in the conventional carrots.
On average, the endophytes in the organic system reduced growth of the A. dauci pathogen by 44%, which was more than twice the protection conferred by endophytes in carrots grown in the conventional soil.
In the field trial, there was no difference in carrot root yield. But pathogen pressure can vary dramatically given environmental conditions, making it difficult to quantify disease suppression in the field. However, given the results of this trial, the scientists suspect that the carrots grown in the organic system would be better able to resist disease if environmental conditions were suitable for the disease to develop.
Variety Choice Matters, Too
Results of these experiments also demonstrated that carrot genotype can play a role in supporting endophytes that can suppress this disease.
In field trials, two of the nine experimental carrot genotypes had 34% and 93% lower disease severity in the organic system versus the conventional. Results of the greenhouse trials confirmed that differences in the ability of different carrot genotypes to resist the disease were related to their ability to host the beneficial endophytes.
“This demonstrates the potential effects of genotype, or variety, on a plant’s ability to harness the benefits of organic, healthy soils,” Hoagland says.
Better understanding of the microbiomes of the soil — and the ways in which breeders and growers can affect them — can lead to invaluable methods of reducing disease, fighting weeds, and addressing other needs of specialty crop growers, she adds.
“We’re still in the early stages of this work, but we see this as tool breeders can use when developing new carrot varieties,” Hoagland says. “Growers, too, may one day be able to impact the number and types of beneficial microbes to protect their plants. If growers focus on the health of their soils, they can see some benefits now.”
Note: The research is part of the Carrot Improvement for Organic Agriculture (CIOA) program, a long-term breeding project aimed at addressing the needs of organic carrot farmers. Funded by USDA’s National Institute of Food and Agriculture, it brings together scientists from Purdue, the USDA’s Agriculture Research Service, the University of Wisconsin, the Organic Seed Alliance, the University of California Riverside, Washington State University, and University of California Extension.
Subscribe Today For
